CHAPTER VIII WATER QUALITY STANDARDS
A. STANDARDS
Many different types of water quality standards have been established in the U.S., some state, some federal. Three types of standards will be presented here, drinking water, wastewater, and ambient. In the area of drinking water, a great deal of regulatory activity has recently occurred, and more is planned. This is a direct result of the signing of the Safe Drinking Water Act Amendments of 1986. Environmental impacts from wastewater discharges are controlled through the NPDES (National Pollution Discharge Elimination System) effluent permit system. The writing of effluent permits often requires a case-by-case evaluation. One of two different sets of standards may be used. The first set is the wastewater effluent standards. The second is an ambient surface water quality standard. In a general sense, both of these sets of standards hold. However, depending on site specific characteristics one set will result in more stringent controls, and it is that one that is used to set the NPDES requirements.
1. Drinking Water
In the U.S., ultimate responsibility for drinking water quality resides with the Environmental Protection Agency (EPA). The Safe Drinking Water Act Amendments of 1986 required that EPA promulgate minimum numbers of standards as directed by congress. Primary standards are developed for pollutants that are thought to have an adverse effect on human health. Secondary standards are guidelines for aesthetic, rather than health reasons. The enforceable primary standards are called maximum contaminant levels (MCLs). These are based on maximum contaminant level goals (MCLGs), levels where no adverse health effect would occur with a margin of safety. The MCLs are set as close to the MCLGs as feasible. The secondary (SMCLs) are also non-enforceable.
As of July 1987, there were 30 primary MCLs (including total coliforms and 3 radionuclides). In May 1989, MCLs were proposed for 27 contaminants not previously regulated (Federal Register, 22 May 1989). In addition, several of the earlier MCLs were modified (silver was dropped entirely). This gives a total of 56 MCLs covering 60 regulated contaminants (THM and Rn MCLs are group standards covering 4 and 2 contaminants respectively). In addition, the EPA has recently proposed monitoring requirements for an additional 113 unregulated contaminants (Federal Register, 22 May 1989). Since, the Safe Drinking Water Act Amendments apply to all water systems serving 25 people or more, the potential monitoring effort is enormous. However, considerable discretion is left to the primacy agency in determining monitoring requirements. Currently all of the states have established primacy except Indiana and Wyoming (and the District of Colombia).
2. Wastewater
These are technology-based standards, and are not dependent on the quality of the receiving waters. At the very least, all dischargers must meet these standards. In some areas subject to water quality degradation, more stringent standards are imposed. For municipal plants, the secondary treatment standards (30 mg/L TSS, 30 mg/L BOD) are applied uniformly. Industrial plants are evaluated based on detailed industry-specific wastewater technology evaluations. Standards may be expressed in terms of mass of pollutant per mass of industrial product, or simply in terms of a maximum effluent concentration. These industry-specific standards may be found in the Code of Federal Regulations, Title 40, Parts 402-699.
3. Ambient Water Quality
When the technology-based standards (above) fail to protect a receiving water so that it can no longer support its intended use, water quality-based standards are imposed. These are published in the "Gold Book" which is periodically updated by the USEPA.
Table 8.1
U.S. Selected Water Quality Standards
Drinking Water |
Waste- |
Surface |
||||
Quality Parameter |
MCL |
SMCL or MCLG |
water |
Water |
||
SENSORY |
||||||
Odor |
|
|||||
GENERAL PHYSICO-CHEMICAL |
||||||
AQUEOUS PHASE |
||||||
Conductivity |
||||||
TDS |
500b |
|||||
SOLID PHASE |
||||||
Turbidity |
0.5 |
|||||
SS |
CP |
V |
||||
pH AND BUFFERING |
||||||
pH |
6.5-8.5b |
CP |
6.5-9 |
|||
Alkalinity |
20 |
|||||
INORGANIC SPECIES |
||||||
METALS |
||||||
Al |
(0.05)b |
|||||
Ag |
0.05 |
(0.09)b |
0.00012 |
|||
As |
0.05 |
(0) |
PP |
0.190 |
||
Ba |
2 |
(5) |
||||
Be |
0.004d |
PP |
0.0053a |
|||
Cd |
0.005c |
(0.005) |
PP |
0.0011 |
||
Cr |
0.1c |
(0.1) |
PP |
0.011 |
||
Cu |
1.3e |
1b |
PP |
0.012 |
||
Fe |
0.3b |
1 |
||||
Hg |
0.002c |
(0.002) |
PP |
0.000012 |
||
Mn |
|
0.05b |
||||
Na |
m&r |
|||||
Ni |
(0.1)g |
(0.1)g |
PP |
0.096 |
||
Pb |
0.015e |
PP |
0.0032 |
|||
Sb |
0.006d |
PP |
1.6a |
|||
Se |
0.05c |
(0.05) |
PP |
0.035 |
||
Tl |
0.002d |
0.0005d |
PP |
0.040a |
||
Zn |
|
5b |
PP |
0.047 |
||
RADIONUCLIDES |
||||||
Beta (mrem) |
4 |
0 |
||||
Gross Alpha (pCi/L) |
15 |
0 |
||||
226Ra + 228Ra (pCi/L) |
5 |
0 |
||||
226Ra (pCi/L) |
20 |
0 |
||||
228Ra (pCi/L) |
20 |
0 |
||||
Rn (pCi/L) |
300 |
0 |
||||
U (pCi/L) |
20 |
0 |
||||
NON-METALS |
||||||
Nitrogen Species |
||||||
Nitrate (as N) |
10.0c |
(10) |
||||
Nitrite (as N) |
1.0c |
(1) |
||||
Ammonia |
V |
|||||
Cyanide |
0.2d |
PP |
0.0052 |
|||
Sulfur Species |
||||||
Sulfate |
500h |
250b |
||||
Sulfide |
0.002 |
|||||
Halides |
||||||
Cl |
250b |
|||||
F |
4 |
4 |
||||
INORGANIC SPECIES (Cont.) |
||||||
Oxidants |
||||||
Oxygen |
V |
|||||
Chlorine |
0.011 |
|||||
Asbestos (fibers/L) |
7x106c |
(7x106) |
PP |
|||
Table 8.1 (Cont.)
U.S. Selected Water Quality Standards
Drinking Water |
Waste- |
Surface |
||
Quality Parameter |
MCL |
SMCL or MCLG |
water |
Water |
ORGANIC SPECIES |
||||
TOTAL ASSAYS |
||||
BOD |
CP |
|||
GROUP ASSAYS |
||||
Oil & Grease |
CP |
V |
||
Surfactants |
2.56a |
|||
Phenols |
||||
Color (Pt-Co Units) |
15b |
V |
||
TOX |
||||
SPECIFIC ANALYSES |
||||
Disinfection Byproducts |
||||
Total Trihalomethanes |
0.10 |
|||
Chloroform |
1.24a |
|||
Total Haloacetic Acids |
(0.060) |
|||
Water Treatment Chemicals |
||||
Acrylamide |
no WQSc,f |
(0) |
||
Epichlorohydrin |
no WQSc,f |
(0) |
||
VOC's (solvents) |
||||
Benzene |
0.005 |
0 |
PP |
|
Carbon Tetrachloride |
0.005 |
0 |
PP |
|
Chlorobenzene |
0.1c |
(0.1) |
PP |
0.50a |
o-Dichlorobenzene |
0.6c |
(0.01)b |
PP |
|
p-Dichlorobenzene |
0.075 |
(0.005)b |
PP |
|
1,2-Dichloroethane |
0.005c |
0 |
PP |
20a |
1,1-Dichloroethylene |
0.007 |
0 |
PP |
|
c-1,2-Dichloroethylene |
0.07c |
(0.07) |
||
t-1,2-Dichloroethylene |
0.1c |
(0.1) |
PP |
|
1,2-Dichloropropane |
0.005 |
(0) |
5.7a |
|
Ethylbenzene |
0.7c |
(0.03)b |
||
Hexachlorobenzene |
0.001d |
0d |
||
Hexachlorocylcopentadiene |
0.05d |
0.05d |
||
Methylene Chloride |
0.005d |
PP |
||
Styrene |
0.1c |
(0) |
||
Tetrachloroethylene |
0.005c |
(0) |
PP |
0.84a |
Toluene |
1.0c |
(0.04)b |
PP |
|
1,2,4-Trichlorobenzene |
0.07d |
PP |
||
1,1,1-Trichloroethane |
0.20 |
0.2 |
PP |
|
1,1,2-Trichloroethane |
0.005d |
PP |
9.4a |
Table 8.1 (Cont.)
U.S. Selected Water Quality Standards
Drinking Water |
Waste- |
Surface |
||
Quality Parameter |
MCL |
SMCL or MCLG |
water |
Water |
ORGANIC SPECIES (Cont.) |
||||
Trichloroethylene (TCE) |
0.005 |
0 |
21.9a |
|
Vinyl Chloride |
0.002 |
0 |
PP |
|
Xylenes |
10c |
(0.02)b |
||
Pesticides |
||||
Alachlor |
0.002c |
(0) |
||
Aldicarb |
0.003 |
0.001 |
||
Aldicarb Sulfoxide |
0.004 |
0.001 |
||
Aldicarb Sulfone |
0.002 |
0.001 |
||
Aldrin/Dieldrin |
PP |
|||
Atrazine |
0.003c |
(0.003) |
||
Carbofuran |
0.04c |
(0.04) |
||
Chlordane |
0.002c |
(0) |
PP |
0.0000043 |
2,4,-D |
0.07c |
(0.07) |
||
Dalapon |
0.2d |
|||
DDE |
PP |
|||
DDT |
PP |
0.000001 |
||
Dibromochloropropane |
0.0002c |
(0) |
||
Dimedon |
||||
Dinoseb |
0.007d |
0.007d |
||
Diquat |
0.02d |
0.02d |
||
Endosulfan |
0.000056 |
|||
Endrin |
0.002d |
0.002d |
PP |
|
Endothal |
0.1d |
0.1d |
||
Ethylene Dibromide |
0.00005c |
(0) |
||
Glyphosate |
0.7d |
0.7d |
||
Guthion |
0.00001 |
|||
Heptachlor |
0.0004c |
(0) |
PP |
0.0000038 |
Heptachlor Epoxide |
0.0002c |
(0) |
PP |
|
Lindane |
0.0002c |
(0.0002) |
||
Malathion |
0.00001 |
|||
Methoxychlor |
0.04c |
(0.4) |
0.00003 |
|
Mirex |
0.000001 |
|||
Parathion |
0.00004 |
|||
Pentachlorophenol |
0.001 |
(0.03)b |
0.0032a |
|
Picloram |
0.5 |
|||
Simazine |
0.004d |
0.004d |
||
Toxaphene |
0.003c |
(0) |
PP |
0.000013 |
2,4,5-TP (Silvex) |
0.05c |
(0.05) |
||
Vydate |
0.2d |
0.2d |
||
Misc. Synthetic Organics |
||||
Benzo(a)-pyrene |
0.002d |
0d |
||
Di(2-ethylhexyl)adipate |
0.4e |
0.4d |
||
Phthalates |
PP |
0.003a |
||
Di(2-ethylhexyl)phthalate |
0.006d |
0d |
||
Hexachlorobenzene |
0.001 |
|||
Hexachlorocyclopentadiene |
0.05d |
0.0052a |
||
PAH's |
none |
PP |
||
PCB's |
0.0005c |
(0) |
PP |
0.000014 |
2,3,7,8-TCDD |
3x10-8 d |
0d |
PP |
<0.00000001a |
Other Priority Pollutants |
||||
129 Pollutants Total |
for European WQ Standards see: Stumm & Morgan, pg. 669 and refs
B. WATER QUALITY PARAMETERS
1. Conventional Pollutants
Taste & Odor
Significance:
Aesthetics,possibly an internal warning ?
Conductivity & TDS
Significance:
assess physiological effects on plants or animals, the purity of distilled water, double check on chemical analysis of major ions,
Turbidity
Definition:
the degree to which a sample scatters light
Significance:
1. aesthetics
2. shortens filter runs, leeds to a poorer quality filtered water
3. protects pathogens during disinfection
pH
Significance:
1. should be between 6 and 9.5 for biological treatment processes
2. should be above 10 for softening processes
3. the higher the better for corrosion control
Acidity
Definition:
the quantitative capacity of a water to neutralize a strong base to a designated pH. It is therefore, an operationaly defined parameter which depends on the pH endpoint chosen.
Composition:
natural waters- mostly carbonic acid and in the case of highly colored waters, humic acids; acid mine drainage- hydrolyzable metal ions such as Fe and Mn; industrial wastes- strong mineral acids may be important.
Significance:
1. acids contribute to corrosion problems
2. consumes bases in an effort to raise pH
Alkalinity
Source:
1. natural waters;dissolution of carbonate rock, algal activity in removing CO2
2. industrial wastes; high concentrations found in boiler waters
Significance:
1. consumes acids in efforts to lower pH
2. Metals
Hardness
Composition:
1. divalent Ca, Mg, Sr, Fe, Mn
Source:
1. natural waters;dissolution of limestone mediated by the low pH conditions in soils which are in turn due to the CO2-releasing bacteria therein
Significance:
1. consumes soap such that more is required to produce a foam
2. leads to precipitation and scaling (deposits yet a protective coat)
Range of Concentrations:
1. natural waters; higher in areas where topsoil is thick and limestone formations are present
mg/L as CaCO3 |
Degree of Hardness |
mM/L |
|||
|
0-75 |
Soft |
0-0.75 |
||
75-150 |
Moderately Hard |
0.75-1.50 |
|||
150-300 |
Hard |
1.50-3.00 |
|||
|
300 up |
Very Hard |
3.00 up |
Aluminum
Source:
1. Natural Waters: dissolution of minerals, rocks and clays (third most abundant element of the earth's crust); Drinking Waters: addition of alum, polyaluminum chloride, etc.
Significance:
1. Can cause encepalophathy in kidney dialysis patients
2. Possible association with Alzheimers Disease
Arsenic
Significance: (Pontius et al., 1994)
1. acute poisoning at high concentrations
Source:
1. Natural Waters: mineral dissolution, insecticides
Range of Concentrations:
Barium
Significance:
1. causes inflictions of the heart (stimulant action), blood vessels and nerves
Source:
1. Dissolution of the mineral, barium sulfate
Range of Concentrations:
1. Drinking Waters: in US between 0.7 mg/L and 900 mg/L with an average of 49 mg/L;
Beryllium
Significance:
1. Inhalation of dust can cause berylliosis, which takes the form of conjunctivitis, acute pneumonitis and chronic pulmonary berylliosis
Source:
1. Industrial Wastes: used for atomic reactors, aircraft, rockets, and missile fuels
Range of Concentrations:
1. Drinking Waters: in US it ranges from 0.01 to 0.7 mg/L with a mean of 0.013 mg/L
Cadmium
Significance:
1. Toxicity: causes adverse changes in the arteries of human kidneys; toxic to certain fish over 200 mg/L
2. may be necessary for the human diet
Range of Concentrations:
1. Drinking Waters: in US it ranges from 0.4 to 60 mg/L with a mean of 8.2 mg/L
Source:
1. Drinking Waters: from galvanized pipe
2. Industrial Wastewaters: yes
Chromium
Composition:
1. hexavalent: soluble, from industrial sources
2. trivalent : very insoluble, rarely found in potable water
Significance:
1. Hexavalent for is an acute systemic poison
Source:
1. Industrial Wastes: used in cooling waters for corrosion control, other uses
Range of Concentrations:
1. Drinking Water: in US it ranges between 3 and 40 ug/L with a mean of 3.2 ug/L
Copper
Significance:
1. Essential to humans, daily adult requirement is 2 mg
Source:
1. Drinking Water: used for controlling biological growths in reservoirs and distribution pipes, used for catalyzing the oxidation of manganese. also from corrosion of copper containing alloys in pipe fittings
Iron
Composition:
1. ferric, Fe(III)
2. ferrous, Fe(II)
Significance:
1. causes staining of laundry and porcelain
2. gives a bittersweet astringent taste, detectable above 1 or 2 mg/l
3. leads to the precipitation of iron hydroxides
Lead
Significance:
1. cumulative human poison: absorption of dietary lead is highest in children (40-50%), lower for adults (5-10%)
Source:
1. Industrial Wastes: mine , smelter and other discharges
2. Drinking Water: dissolution of old lead plumbing
Range of Concentrations:
1. Drinking Water: in US it ranges from 0 to 20 ug/L
Manganese
Composition:
1. divalent-principal form in ground waters due to low oxygen
2. trivalent and tetravalent - principal form in surface waters, as soluble complexes and in suspension
3. heptavalent-used to oxidize the divalent form
Significance:
1. stains laundry and plumbing fixtures
Mercury
Significance:
1. both organic and inorganic salts are very toxic
2. subject to biological magnification, through transformation to methylmercury; therefore, ingestion through food is major contributor of body burden
3. methylmercury poisoning: mental disturbance, impairment of speach, hearing, vision, and movement.
Selenium
Significance:
1. toxic effects on man and animals similar to that of As
2. suspected carcinogen
3. causes dental caries
Range of Concentrations:
1. Drinking Waters: generally less than 10 ug/L
Silver
Significance:
1. causes argyria, a permanent blue-gray discoloration of the skin and eyes
2. causes pathologic changes in the kidnets, liverm and spleen (of rats) at concentrations of 0.4 to 1 mg/l
Source:
1. Swimming Pool Waters: used as a bactericide
Range of Concentrations:
1. Drinking Waters: in US it ranges up to 2 ug/L with a mean of 0.13 ug/L
Sodium
Significance:
1. certain maladies require a water with low sodium concentrations
2. soil permeability may be reduced by high sodium to total cation ratio
3. feed waters for high pressure boilers require concentrations of no more than 2 or 3 mg/L
Vanadium
Significance:
1. Vanadium pentoxide dust causes gastrointestinal and respiratory disturbances
2. Va may help prevent heart disease according to epidemiologicl evidence
Source:
1. Industrial Wastes: used in dyeing, ceramics, ink, and catalyst manufacture
Range of Concentrations:
1. Drinking Water: in US average concentration is 6 ug/L
Zinc
Significance:
1. causes a bitter astringent taste and an opalescence in alkaline waters at concentrations above 5 mg/l
2. essential to human growth
3. may indicate the presence of lead and cadmium because they are common impurieties in the zinc used in galvanizing
Source:
1. Drinking Water: deterioration of galvanized iron pipe
Range of Concentrations:
1. Drinking Water: in US it ranges from 0.06 to 7.0 mg/l with a mean of 1.33 mg/l
3. Inorganic Non-metals
Nitrogen Species
Significance:
1. stimulates or supports biological growth in natural and engineered systems
Nitrate
Significance:
1. high concentrations cause methemoglobinemia in infants. Can become reduced in the infant intestine to nitrite, which absorbs into the blood and oxidizes the iron in hemoglobin.
Source:
1. fertilizer in agricultural runoff
Nitrite
Significance:
1. Can cause methemoglobinemia in infants as with nitrate. Absorbs into the blood and oxidizes the iron in hemoglobin.
Source:
1. Partial denitrification of nitrate
2. Partial nitrification of ammonia
3. Industrial
Ammonia
Significance:
1. indicator of recent pollution by domestic wastewater
2. leads to consumption of oxygen and some other oxidants like chlorine
Sulfur Species
Significance:
1. reduction or presence of hydrogen sulfide causes corrosion in sewers
Chloride
Significance:
1. aesthetics; above 250 mg/L one detects a salty taste
2. used to monitor for sea water intrusion
3. has been used as an environmental tracer
Fluoride
Significance:
1. helps prevent dental caries
2. excess causes fluorosis,
Dissolved Oxygen
Significance:
1. certain concentrations are needed to provide liveable environments for bacteria in biological treatment processes and for aquatic organisms
4. General Organics
Organics (TOC, COD, BOD, Color)
Significance:
1. leads to the consumption of treatment chemicals (coagulants, oxidants)
2. leads to the formation of oxidant by-products
Color
Source:
1. natural organic matter; ie, humics
2. WW discharges: lignin in paper wastes; dyeing WW's
Significance:
1. aesthetic
Oxidants (chlorine, ozone, chlorine dioxide)
Significance:
1. must be present at a sufficient concentration for a sufficient period of time to achieve proper disinfection
2. must avoid overdose because: chemicals are expensive, both residual oxidant and oxidant by-products may have adverse health effects
Volatile Acids
Significance:
1. control of anaerobic waste treatment processes, their presence may indicate a faltering methanogen population -(Switzenbaum?)
TOX
Significance:
1. Indicator of hazardous chlorination byproducts in treated waters and wastewaters
2. General indicator of anthropogenic pollutants
PCB's
Significance:
1. toxic, and extremely persistent in the environment.
Source:
1. Industrial: electrical capacitors, transformers, paints, plastics, insecticides
Trihalomethanes
Significance:
1. animal carcinogens and mutagens
Source:
1. byproducts of chlorination, especially under conditions of high chlorine dose, high TOC, long reaction time, and high pH
Polynuclear Aromatic Hydrocarbons (PAHs)
Significance:
1. May be metabolized in the body (formation of epoxide, then diol from benzo(a)pyrene) to form carcinogenic byproducts
Source:
1. Incomplete combustion of other hydrocarbons, especially from engine exhausts, wood stove smoke, cigarette smoke, coal tars, petroleum residues
5. Volatile Organic Compounds
Vinyl Chloride
Significance:
1. human and animal carcinogen
2. acute and chronic toxic effects
Source:
1. synthesis of polyvinyl chloride resins for construction
Trichloroethylene
Significance:
1. exposure to high concentrations can cause acute depression of the central nervous system
2. carcinogenic and mutagenic activity uncertain
Source:
1. metal degreasing solvent, dry-cleaning solvent, inorganic sythesis, refrigerants, and fumigants
Tetrachloroethylene
Significance:
1. exposure to high concentrations can cause acute depression of the central nervous system
Source:
1. solvent, heat transfer liquid, manufacture of fluorocarbons
Carbon Tetrachloride
Significance:
1. animal carcinogen
2. highly persistent in the environment
Source:
1. general solvent, cleaning agent, component in fire extinguishers, grain fumigants
1,2-Dichlorethane
Significance:
1. may be an animal carcinogen
2. acute exposure causes central nervous system depression and damage to liver and kidneys
Source:
1. used as a metal degreaser, varnish remover, wetting agent, insecticide fumigant, manufacture of viny chloride and tetraethyl lead
6. Pesticides
Endrin
Significance:
1. animal carcinogen (hepatocarcinogen), may also affect CNS
Source:
1. insecticide
Lindane
Significance:
1. animal carcinogen
Source:
1.
Methoxychlor
Significance:
1. low mamalian toxicity
2. not very persistent in the environment
Source:
1. insecticide
Toxaphene
Significance:
1. chronic toxicant, epileptic-type convulsions
Source:
1. Once the most widely-used insecticide in the U.S.; composed of more than 170 chlorinated camphene compounds, often represented by the empirical formula: