|
LENTICULAR |
Introduction
Of the nearly hundred lenticular truss bridges that are estimated to have been built between about 1878 and 1895 in the Commonwealth of Massachusetts, only nine are known to exist. Only three of these bridges are currently open and in use for vehicular traffic. Of the remaining six, three are closed to vehicular traffic, two have been restored and relocated as pedestrian bridges, and one has been dismantled and is currently in open storage, awaiting reuse. The authors visited each of the bridges in Massachusetts, measured the dimensions of the critical members, and documented their condition.
Lenticular Truss Bridges
During the latter part of the 19th Century the Berlin Iron Bridge Co. of East Berlin, Connecticut manufactured and erected almost 800 lenticular truss bridges in the United States (Darnell 1979). While most of these bridges were built in New England, a few were constructed in Ohio and Texas. These bridges are sometimes referred to as "pumpkin-seed bridges", "cats-eyes bridges", "elliptical truss bridges", or "parabolic truss bridges" because of their unique lense shape. Lenticular bridges were only used for vehicular traffic and were generally considered too light to be used for railroad and trolley loads.
Darnell (1979) described a number of these bridges and gives a detailed account of the Berlin Iron Bridge Co. The Berlin Iron Bridge Co. also built conventional steel truss bridges and even built a few pedestrian suspension bridges, the most notable in Keesville, N.Y. and Milford, N.H. In addition to bridges, the Berlin Iron Bridge Co. also built roof trusses, water towers, and steel frames for buildings, as the ads below show.
The Patents of William O. Douglas
A patent was issued by the U.S. Patent office on April 16, 1878 to William O. Douglas, Binghampton, N.Y., for a truss bridge, described in the patent as "A combination of two or more elliptical trusses connected as herein describes with the floor and joints and necessary flooring to form a through deck or swing bridge". A number of the bridges had been built by the Corrugated Metal Company, a small manufacturing plant located in Berlin, Ct. The name of the company was changed to the Berlin Iron Bridge Company sometime around 1883 and, according to company literature, they provided almost 90% of the iron bridges roadway bridges throughout New England from 1880 to 1890. Designs included both Pony Truss and Through Truss configurations with deck placements that included: suspended deck; through deck; middeck; and underdeck designs. A second patent was granted to Douglas for improvements on his design on April 7, 1885.
Surviving Lenticular Bridges in Massachusetts
The accompanying figure shows the location of the remaining lenticular truss bridges in Massachusetts.
The design of the individual elements was exquisitely simple, yet functionally good, and lent itself to economic fabrication at the plant. The use of riveted plates, angles, and channel sections to build the top chords and vertical posts is characteristic of all the bridges. The construction brings to mind a child’s Erector set and one can easily imagine the individual top chord elements, vertical posts, lower chords, bracing bars and other smaller components being transported to the site by horse carts. Assembly at the site would have been relatively easy and fast, even by today’s standards. There are relatively few variations in components among the surviving bridges, and the components suggest a simple modular design concept. After all, the market for iron bridges at the end of the 19th century was highly competitive and therefore any means to reduce fabrication costs would have been exercised.
In comparison with typical bridge sections of today, the components for a lenticular pony truss were relatively light and could have been handled by workers at the site. For example, if we use the Fort River Bridge in South Amherst as an example, a 14.75 ft. long upper chord would weigh about 640 lbs; an 8 ft. long vertical post would weight about 130 lbs; and a 14.75 ft. long lower eye chord would weight about 105 lbs. Each of these members is constructed of individual components riveted together. The weight of the upper chord is such that it would likely have been handled by a tripod or boom and jib. The other elements could easily be placed by two workers.
Surviving Lenticular Pony Truss Bridges
The Golden Hill Road –Lee shows a recent photograph of the Golden Hill Road Bridge located in Lee, Ma. The bridge is a typical example of a Berlin Iron Bridge Co. Lenticular Pony Truss.
Other Surviving Lenticular Pony Truss Bridges
| Pumpkin Hollow Road - Great Barrington | Fort River - South Amherst | |
| Gilbert Road - West Warren | Blackstone River Bikeway - Millbury | |
| North Canal - Lawrence |
Surviving Lenticular Through Truss Bridges
| Galvin Road - North Adams | Bardwell’s Ferry Road - Shelburne | |
| Aiken Street - Lowell |
A listing of other existing lenticular truss bridges known to the authors is given in Table 2.
References
Chamberlin, W.P., 2000. Hadley, New York’s Parabolic Truss: "Catalog Bridges" and the Engineering of Structural Art. Proceedings of the 7th Historic Bridges Conference, pp. 94-105.
Darnell, V., 79. Lenticular Bridges from East Berlin, Connecticut. Journal of the Society for Zindustrial Archeology. Vol. 5, No. 1, pp. 19-32.
Drew, B.A., 1979. Lenticular Bridges in the Berkshires. Journal of the Society for Industrial Archeology, Vol. 5, No. 1, pp. 69-70.
Drew, B.A., 1990. Spanning Berkshire Waterways. Attic Revivals Press, Great Barrington, Ma., 36 pp.
Fleming, R., 1928. Early Parabolic Truss Bridges Gradually Disappearing. Engineering News Record, Vol. 100, No. 10, pp. 748-749.
Table 1. Surviving Lenticular Truss Bridges in Massachusetts.
|
No. |
Bridge |
Town |
Type1 |
Spanning |
Span |
|
1 |
Golden Hill Rd. |
Lee |
P |
Housatonic R. |
60.2 (81) |
|
2 |
Galvin Rd. |
N. Adams |
T |
Hoosac R. |
31.4 (103) |
|
3 |
Pumpkin Hollow Rd. |
Great Barrington |
P |
(see Note1) |
17.7 (58) |
|
4 |
Bardwell’s Ferry Rd. |
Shelburne |
T |
Deerfield R. |
60.2 (197.5) |
|
5 |
Fort River |
South Amherst |
P |
Fort R. |
18.0 (59) |
|
6 |
Gilbert Rd. |
West Warren |
P |
Quabog R. |
21.9 (72) |
|
7 |
Blackstone Bikeway |
Millbury |
P |
Blackstone River |
22.6 (74) |
|
8 |
Aiken Street |
Lowell |
T |
Merrimac R. |
46.6 (153) |
|
9 |
North Canal |
Lawrence |
P |
N. Canal |
25.3 (83) |
Table 2. Extant Lenticular Truss Bridges.
|
State |
Town |
Bridge Type |
Span |
| Vermont |
Highgate Falls Highgate Falls |
Pony Truss Through Truss |
N/A N/A |
| New Hampshire |
Delage Rd., Franconia Dow Ave., Franconia Livermore Falls, Compton Depot Rd., N. Chichester |
Pony Truss Pony Truss Under Deck Through Truss |
56 ft. - 4 panel 69 ft. - 5 panel N/A 95 ft. - 6 panel |
|
Connecticut |
Main Street, Talcottville Washington Ave., Waterbury Sheffield Street, Waterbury Minortown Rd., Woodbury W. Main Street, Stamford Oliver Street, Stamford Brunswick Ave, Moosup Main Street, Moosup Lover's Leap, New Milford Boardman's Rd., New Milford |
Pony Truss Pony Truss Pony Truss Pony Truss Pony Truss (2) Pony Truss Through Truss Through Truss Through Truss Through Truss |
61 ft. - 4 panel 67.5 ft.-5 panel 53 ft. - 4 panel 63 ft. - 4 panel 60.5 ft.-5 panel 53 ft. - 4 panel 124 ft.- 8 panel N/A. - 7 panel 173 ft.-10 panel 188 ft.-10 panel |
| New York |
Water Street, Homer Water Street, Homer Wall Street, Homer Pine Street, Homer Cemetery Road, Salem Rhule Road, Malta Schaghtokhe, Mechanicsville Silk Street, Newark Valley Corinth Road, Hadley Kelsey Street, Candor Raymondville (W) Ouaquaga, Colesville Washington St., Binghampton Corinth Road, Hadley |
Pony Truss Pony Truss Pony Truss Pony Truss Pony Truss Pony Truss Pony Truss Pony Truss Pony Truss Through Truss Through Truss Through Truss (2) Through Truss (3) Half Through Truss |
4-5 ft. - 4 panel 52.5 ft.- 4 panel 58 ft. - 4 panel 71 ft. - 5 panel 51 ft. - 4 panel N/A N/A 70 ft. - 5 panel 44 ft. - 3 panel 98 ft. - 8 panel N/A 170 ft.-10 panel 160 ft. - 9 panel 136 ft. - 9 panel |
| New Jersey |
Mahwah Neshanic Station |
Pony Truss Through Truss (2) |
N/A 140.5 ft.-8 panel |
| Rhode Island |
Stillwater Rd., Smithfield Interlaken Mills, Arkwright |
Pony Truss |
50 ft. - panel N/A |
|
Pennsylvania |
Duncannon Jersey Shore, Lycoming Co. Pierceville, Wyoming Co. Waterville, Lebanon Co. Nicholson Township |
Pony Truss Through Truss (W) Through Truss Through Truss (W) Through Truss |
81 ft.-5 panel 287 ft. 114 ft.-8 panel 221 ft.-12 panel 114 ft.-8 panel |
| Texas |
Augusta Street, San Antonio Crockett Street, San Antonio S. Presa Street, San Antonio Dodds Creek, Coryell Co. Plum Creek 173, Caldwell Co. Plum Creek 230, Caldwell Co. Yancey Rd., Frio Co. Brackenridge, San Antonio Kelley Crossing, Caldwell Co. |
Pony Truss Pony Truss Pony Truss Pony Truss Pony Truss Pony Truss Through Truss Through Truss Pony Truss |
N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A 89 ft. - 6 panel |